What a fun theme, Debby!!
Panthercap Mushroom. Oops, poisonous, not good for the soup.
How about some stone crab claws? These are already cracked and ready for the pot. The fishermen cut one claw off the crab and throw it back, and the claw grows back.
Maybe someone would like some fresh guacamole to top a salad or on crackers. Mmmmm.....